Search icon
Download the all-new Republic app:

Published 22:23 IST, July 3rd 2023

Former English cricketer schools Ben Stokes over controversial Jonny Bairstow dismissal

Jonny Bairstow's dismissal in the 2nd innings of the Lord's Test match has sparked a widespread debate over the application of the 'Spirit of the Game'

Reported by: Anirban Sarkar
Ben Stokes and Travis head discussing Jonny Bairstow's controversial dismissal on the fifth day of the 2nd Ashes Test(Image: AP) | Image: self

Australia's win over England in the 2nd Test did witness some controversial moments. The visitors have taken a 2-0 lead in the 5 match Test Ashes series. It remains to be seen whether they can register a comeback in the next match at Headingley. Australia are the defending champions of the coveted urn and haven't let England win the title for the past 8 years now.

3 things you need to know

  • Ben Stokes was the top scorer for England in the second innings with an excellent 155
  • James Anderson hasn't been able to deliver so far in Ashes 2023
  • Australia will retain the Ashes with another victory in the third Test

Jonny Bairstow's dismissal invites contrasting reactions

Former England pacer Steve Harmison claimed Alex Carey did the right thing by dislodging the stumps of Jonny Bairstow. The England wicket keeper ducked a Cameron Green bouncer and decided to leave his crease as he thought the umpire called it an over. 

"Carey utilised the opportunity to remove the bells and later after a lengthy review by the third umpire, he was adjudged out. The incident sparked a lot of debate but during his conversation with Talksport, Harmison stated that Carey did the right thing.

Read More: UK PM Rishi Sunak comes down hard on Australia over breaching 'spirit of cricket'

It is yeah but he is out it's as simple as that. The spirit of the game it only works when the side you're on you feel hard done by. I love Jonny Bairstow but he made a mistake. He left his crease. You can't leave the crease. End of the over yes! The only thing from Ben Stokes' point of view when Ben was saying the spirit of the cricket had the umpire sort of called over and had he made the gesture to move away from the over. Then you've got a litttle bit of grey area. But the umpire stood still.

Steve Harmison backed australian wicketkeeper Alex Carey 

"Jonny Bairstow was in his crease with both feet when Alex Carey let go of the ball. The ball was in mid-air when Bairstow left the crease. You can see he was in or whatever you want but at the end of the day he did it to Steve Smith. Smith was out of his crease when he was batting and Bairstow caught the ball, threw the ball to the stumps.", said Harmison while supporting his claims.

Aread More: Ashes 2023: England commit the same mistakes against Australia as India in WTC 2023 Final

"That's exactly what Alex carey did. At the end of the day Bairstow should have never left his crease. He did it 3 or 4 times. So Carey decided to throw the ball to the stumps and he actualluy timed it perfectly." Harmison further added

Updated 22:26 IST, July 3rd 2023

LIVE TV

Republic TV is India's no.1 English news channel since its launch.